What is communism?
Communism names two things that are often mixed up. In Marx's theory it is a future classless, stateless society in which goods are shared by need. In twentieth-century history it is the movement and the one-party states, beginning with Russia in 1917, that said they were building toward that goal under a communist party. Those states called themselves socialist, not communist, and scholars still argue over what to call them.
The historical record includes mass death and repression. Famines linked to state policy killed millions in the Soviet Union in 1931-34 and tens of millions in China in 1959-61, and Soviet records show roughly 680,000 executions in 1937-38 alone. Historians agree these events happened and disagree on the totals, on intent, and on whether adding them into one figure such as 100 million is sound.
The record also includes communist involvement in Black and anti-colonial struggles: the Scottsboro defence, organisers such as Claudia Jones and Harry Haywood, Cuban troops in Angola and Soviet training for the African National Congress. In the United States and Canada, anti-communism was used against civil rights and labour figures, including W. E. B. Du Bois, Paul Robeson and Martin Luther King Jr., and through laws such as Quebec's Padlock Act. This file sorts each claim by the strength of its evidence and shows critics and defenders side by side.
Lenses on communism
- definitional scholarship
- Separates communism as Marx's end goal from communist-party states, and asks what reference works and theorists mean by each.
- historical
- Follows the main events in order: 1848, 1917, 1949, 1959, 1989-91, with Canada and the United States alongside Europe, Asia, Africa and the Caribbean.
- demographic history
- Weighs famine and repression death counts from archives and population data, and shows where qualified historians disagree.
- critics
- Presents the case that communist rule led by its nature to dictatorship, famine and terror, using its best sources.
- defenders and revisionists
- Presents scholars who dispute inflated totals, stress context such as war and invasion, or point to social gains and anti-colonial support.
- Black liberation
- Looks at Black, Caribbean and African people inside communist movements and at what those movements did and failed to do for them.
- anti-colonial
- Reads Soviet and Cuban involvement in African liberation wars as both solidarity and state interest.
- civil liberties
- Examines what governments did in the name of anti-communism: surveillance, passport denials, deportation, detention and censorship.
- womanist and gender
- Asks what formal equality laws changed for women and what stayed the same, and centres Black women communists such as Claudia Jones.
- disability justice
- Asks how communist states treated disabled people, including work-based classification and institutions; little of this could be sourced in this round.
Communism: the words, plainly
- Black Belt thesis
- The Comintern position of 1928 and 1930 that African Americans in the Deep South formed a nation with a right to self-determination.
- COINTELPRO
- FBI counterintelligence programme of 1956-1971 that secretly disrupted the Communist Party and later civil rights and Black power groups.
- Communism
- In Marx's theory, a classless and stateless society that shares goods by need; in common use, the movement and one-party states led by communist parties.
- Communist International (Comintern)
- The Moscow-based body that directed communist parties around the world in the 1920s and 1930s.
- Communist-party state
- A state ruled by a single communist party; five remain: China, Cuba, Laos, North Korea and Vietnam.
- Double burden
- Women carrying both full-time paid work and most unpaid housework.
- Excess deaths
- Deaths above the number expected in normal conditions, the usual measure for famine tolls.
- Great Leap Forward
- China's 1958-1960 campaign of communes and crash industrialisation, followed by mass famine.
- Gulag
- The Soviet system of forced labour camps and colonies.
- Holodomor
- The famine of 1932-33 in Soviet Ukraine, recognised as genocide by many states and debated as such by historians.
- International Labor Defense
- The legal arm of the U.S. Communist Party, best known for defending the Scottsboro defendants.
- Marxism-Leninism
- The official doctrine of Soviet-type states, combining Marx's ideas with rule by a single vanguard party.
- Padlock Act
- Quebec law of 1937 that let the attorney general lock any building used to spread communism.
- Red Scare / McCarthyism
- Periods of official and public campaigns against suspected communists in the United States, strongest in the late 1940s and 1950s.
- Smith Act
- U.S. law used to prosecute Communist Party leaders for advocating the overthrow of the government.